Low-Sugar Drinks to Swap for Soda
Cutting soda does not mean drinking plain water forever. Here are six lower-sugar swaps, what each one tastes like, and how to ease off the habit.

CreamsicleEP-633
We may earn a commission if you buy through links in this guide. How we make money
Flavored sparkling water
It keeps the fizz and the cold crunch of soda with little or no sugar.
A can of regular soda often has around ten teaspoons of sugar. Most people who want to drink less of it do not miss the sugar so much as the fizz, the cold, and the small ritual of opening a can. The good swaps keep those three things.
Below are six options, from nearest to soda to furthest. Try one or two instead of changing everything at once. Gradual swaps stick better than a hard stop.
Start with the fizz
If bubbles are what you crave, begin here.
- Plain or flavored sparkling water. Brands like LaCroix, Bubly and Spindrift (which uses real fruit juice, so check its label) come in lots of flavors. Most have no sugar. Add a squeeze of lemon or lime and it feels like a real drink.
- Diet or zero-sugar soda. These taste closest to the original. They use sweeteners instead of sugar. Opinions on sweeteners differ, so if you have a health concern, ask your doctor.
- Prebiotic or "better-for-you" sodas such as Olipop or Poppi. They are lower in sugar than regular soda, though they are not sugar-free, so read the label.
Then try flavor without bubbles
When the fizz craving fades, still drinks open up more choices.
- Iced tea, unsweetened or lightly sweetened. Brew a pitcher and flavor it with fruit or mint. Our guide to cold brew iced tea at home shows an easy way to do it.
- Drink mixes that sweeten without sugar. Single-serve packets turn a bottle of water into something flavored. The Loaded Teashop makes green tea mixes with no artificial colors or flavors, and we explain them in this post on loaded tea. Check the nutrition panel of whatever you choose, since sweetener types vary.
- Fruit-infused water. Slice cucumber, berries or citrus into a pitcher. It is faint in flavor, but it works if you want something simple.
A quick comparison
| Swap | Fizz | Sweetness | Good to know |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sparkling water | Yes | None to light | Easy first step |
| Zero-sugar soda | Yes | High | Closest to the original |
| Prebiotic soda | Yes | Medium | Lower sugar, not zero |
| Unsweetened iced tea | No | None | Has caffeine unless herbal |
| Flavored drink mix | No | Varies | Read the label |
| Infused water | No | Faint | Cheapest option |
How to make the switch stick
- Pick the moment you drink soda most. Lunch, the afternoon slump, or dinner. Swap only that one.
- Stock the swap where the soda used to be. Put sparkling water at the front of the fridge. If it is easy to grab, you will grab it.
- Make it cold. Much of soda's appeal is temperature and crunchy ice. Use a tall glass and plenty of ice.
- Step down gradually. Mix half soda and half sparkling water for a week or two, then change the ratio.
- Keep a treat. A can now and then is fine. The goal is a new default, not a perfect record.
What to watch for on labels
"Low sugar" can mean different things. Check grams of added sugar per serving, and check the serving size, since a bottle can hold two or more servings. Juice-based drinks add natural sugar that still counts. If you manage diabetes or any health condition, talk with your doctor or a dietitian about which drinks fit your plan.
Caffeine and cravings
Many people drink soda for the caffeine as much as the taste. If you quit cold, a headache or a slump around three in the afternoon is common for a few days. Replace the caffeine on purpose. A cup of tea, a small coffee, or an unsweetened iced tea can fill the gap while your habit shifts. If you are sensitive to caffeine, or you drink soda late in the day, pick herbal tea or a caffeine-free sparkling water for evenings. Drink a glass of plain water first when a craving hits. Sometimes thirst is what you are feeling, and by the time you finish the glass, the craving has eased.
The bottom line
The easiest swap is sparkling water with a little citrus. If you want something closer to soda, a zero-sugar can does the job. If you want to leave fizz behind, try iced tea or a flavored mix. Choose one swap this week and see how you feel about it.
Photo: Vess Beverage Co, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons.


